New Study Reveals Affordable, Effective Treatment for Bad Breath in Kids
The study, published in PLOS ONE, examined 52 children aged 6-12 who were mouth breathers and experienced halitosis.
A study conducted by researchers in Brazil demonstrates that antimicrobial photodynamic therapy, utilizing blue light to target annatto colorant, is a viable and effective treatment for halitosis in children who breathe through their mouths.
Annatto is an orange-reddish pigment derived from the seeds of Bixa orellana (achiote or urucum), a shrub native to tropical parts of the Americas.
Mouth breathing dries up the saliva, reducing its antibacterial and cleansing effects, so that halitosis is likely to worsen as a result. Halitosis is the medical term for bad breath, which may reflect local or systemic conditions such as gingivitis, periodontal disease, diabetic acidosis, hepatic failure, or respiratory infection.
An article on the study is published in the journal PLOS ONE.
The researchers selected 52 mouth-breathing children aged 6-12 with a diagnosis of halitosis confirmed using an inexpensive halimeter available from online retailers (enabling dentists to perform the diagnostic protocol easily in their consulting rooms).
The first author of the article is Laura Hermida Cardoso, a PhD candidate under the Interinstitutional Doctorate Program (Dinter) run by Nove de Julho University (UNINOVE) in São Paulo (Brazil) and the Catholic University of Uruguay (UCU) in Montevideo. The co-authors are all researchers at the Metropolitan University of Santos (UNIMES) in São Paulo state.
Antimicrobial photodynamic therapy (aPDT) consists of the administration of a photosensitizer combined with a light source at a specific wavelength, and oxygen. The procedure generates reactive oxygen species that induce bacterial cell death. Although the study only involved children, the method can treat halitosis in people of any age.
“The photosensitizer used in the study was annatto, which is reddish and was targeted by blue light from an LED [light-emitting diode] in the photopolymerizing device most dentists now have in their consulting rooms, facilitating adoption of the protocol,” said pediatric dentist Sandra Kalil Bussadori, last author of the article and full professor in the Medical Biophotonics and Rehabilitation Sciences Graduate Studies Program at UNINOVE.
Bussadori, who is also a full professor at UNIMES and chairs the Brazilian Pediatric Dentistry Association (ABOPED), recalled that she has observed many cases of halitosis when treating children and adolescents. “These observations led me to study halitosis in depth with the aim of developing simple and effective treatment protocols,” she said.
FAPESP supported the study via two projects (19/14229-6 and 22/16828-7).
Affordability
According to Bussadori, any reference to photodynamic therapy in an academic context brings to mind as the first option the usual method that involves methylene blue photosensitizer and red laser light. “But why not offer health professionals a more affordable option? It was this insight that led me to develop a photosensitizer for use with the LED photopolymerization device dentists already have. For devices fitted with a blue LED, we would need to develop a red colorant. That’s why I thought of annatto,” she said.
After several formulations, in vitro experiments, and clinical trials, Bussadori succeeded in perfecting an annatto spray, which she patented in 2020. Annatto pods and seeds are dark red when ripe.
The 52 children that met the criteria for inclusion in the study were given instructions on toothbrushing with fluoridated toothpaste and dental flossing three times per day after meals for 30 days.
They were randomly divided into two groups. One was given aPDT applied to the middle third of the dorsal surface of the tongue. The other used a tongue scraper and did not receive aPDT. Both groups used toothbrushing and flossing as noted.
In the single session of aPDT performed, the annatto photosensitizer was sprayed onto the tongue at a concentration of 20% in a sufficient quantity to coat the middle third of the dorsum (five sprays) and left for two minutes to incubate. Six points were irradiated with a distance of 1 cm between points, a beam area of 2 cm per point, and exposure of 20 seconds per point. Halitosis and tongue coating results before and after treatment, and seven and 30 days later, were analyzed and compared.
Whitish or yellowish tongue coating is made up mainly of bacteria, metabolites, and food debris that usually accumulate on the posterior portion of the tongue dorsum. Several studies have demonstrated that there is a correlation between tongue coating and excessive concentrations of volatile sulfur compounds produced by bacteria, leading to bad breath, but the study led by Bussadori did not find a direct correlation between tongue coating and halitosis in mouth-breathing children. “The main cause of bad breath in these children appears to be oral dryness due to mouth breathing,” she said.
Halitosis improved significantly in both groups, but more so in the group that received aPDT.
Halitosis can result in social problems, impair quality of life, and indicate more serious medical conditions. In children, it can have a negative influence on psychological development in a critical period of social interaction.
Reference: “Assessment of photodynamic therapy with annatto and led for the treatment of halitosis in mouth-breathing children: Randomized controlled clinical trial” by Laura Hermida Bruno, Amanda Rafaelly Honório Mandetta, Ana Paula Taboada Sobral, Marcela Leticia Leal Gonçalves, Elaine Marcilio Santos, Ana Laura Fossati, Juliana Maria Altavista Sagretti Gallo, Pamella de Barros Motta, Alessandro Melo Deana, Anna Carolina Ratto Tempestini Horliana, Lara Jansiski Motta, Raquel Agnelli Mesquita Ferrari, Kristianne Porta Santos Fernandes and Sandra Kalil Bussadori, 3 September 2024, PLOS ONE.
DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0307957
